By Koushiik Kumar | CORD
Which route fits your dispute?
These forums serve different purposes, and more than one can apply to the same loan. Start with what the dispute is about: the table shows the usual route for each kind of loan dispute and where institutional arbitration fits.
|
Nature of the dispute |
Usual route |
Where institutional arbitration fits |
|
Lender wants to enforce security over a secured asset of a non-performing account |
SARFAESI, subject to the section 31 exclusions |
It does not: enforcing a mortgage or other security interest is not arbitrable (Booz Allen & Hamilton Inc. v. SBI Home Finance Ltd., (2011) 5 SCC 532) |
|
Bank or financial institution recovering a debt of Rs 20 lakh or more |
Debt Recovery Tribunal |
It does not: claims within the DRT's jurisdiction are not arbitrable (Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation, (2021) 2 SCC 1) |
|
Contractual money claim under a loan agreement outside the DRT's jurisdiction, such as a smaller unsecured loan |
Arbitration if the agreement provides for it; otherwise the civil court |
The main route, where the loan agreement named the institution and its rules before the dispute |
|
Co-lending, lending service provider or vendor contract dispute |
Arbitration or mediation under the contract |
The main route, where the contract names the institution |
|
Both sides are ready to settle |
Lok Adalat, or mediation |
Institutional mediation is an alternative route to a settlement |
|
Borrower complaint about deficiency in service |
Complaint to the lender, then the RBI Ombudsman if the lender is covered by RB-IOS 2026 |
Not a substitute: the complaint route stays open |
How do the forums compare?
|
Forum |
Law |
What it decides |
Needs both parties' agreement? |
Limits |
Outcome and challenge |
|
Arbitration |
Contractual claims under the loan, co-lending or vendor agreement |
Yes: an arbitration agreement |
Rights in rem, such as enforcing a mortgage, are not arbitrable |
Award enforceable like a decree (s.36); challenge on limited grounds (s.34) |
|
|
SARFAESI |
Enforcement of a security interest in secured assets of a non-performing account |
No |
Does not apply to a security interest for securing repayment of a financial asset not exceeding one lakh rupees (s.31(h)), a security interest created in agricultural land (s.31(i)), or a case in which the amount due is less than twenty per cent of the principal amount and interest thereon (s.31(j)) |
Possession and sale of the secured asset; borrower may apply to the DRT (s.17) |
|
|
Debt Recovery Tribunal |
Recovery claims by banks and financial institutions |
No |
Debt of Rs 20 lakh or more (S.O. 4312(E), 6 September 2018) |
Recovery certificate; appeal to the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal |
|
|
Lok Adalat |
Settlement, before or during litigation |
Yes: both must agree to the settlement |
Cannot decide a dispute the parties do not settle |
Award deemed a civil court decree, final, no appeal (s.21) |
|
|
RBI Ombudsman |
Borrower complaints about deficiency in service |
No (borrower complains first to the lender) |
Not a forum for a lender's claim. The Scheme covers banks but only certain NBFCs: those authorised to accept deposits, or with a customer interface and assets of Rs 100 crore or more on the date of the previous year's audited balance sheet |
Decision under the Scheme |
Does arbitration replace SARFAESI or the DRT?
No. The Supreme Court has held that rights in rem are generally not arbitrable, and that a suit to enforce a mortgage is a right in rem (Booz Allen & Hamilton Inc. v. SBI Home Finance Ltd., (2011) 5 SCC 532). A claim for money due under the loan contract is a right in personam, which arbitration can decide. SARFAESI and the DRT follow their own statutory processes. Claims by banks and financial institutions that fall within the Debt Recovery Tribunal's jurisdiction are also not arbitrable (Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation, (2021) 2 SCC 1).
When does arbitration fit a loan dispute?
Arbitration fits claims under a contract where both parties agreed to it in advance. That includes unsecured personal and business loans, claims below the DRT threshold, co-lending disputes between a bank and an NBFC, and disputes with lending service providers or vendors. It does not fit where one party chose the forum alone (Radiance Galore v. Yes Bank Ltd., 2025:BHC-OS:10788).
When does a Lok Adalat fit?
A Lok Adalat fits where both sides are ready to settle. Its award is final and cannot be appealed, which gives certainty, but it can only record what the parties agree. If they do not settle, the matter returns to the ordinary route.
What should borrowers know?
A borrower is not limited to the forum the lender starts. A service complaint goes first to the lender, then to the RBI Ombudsman, if the lender is covered by the Scheme. A SARFAESI measure can be challenged before the DRT. An arbitration can be challenged where the borrower did not agree to the institution or was not given a fair hearing.
For contractual lending disputes, CORD offers online arbitration for banks and NBFCs under published CORD Rules 2.0, with the arbitrator appointed by CORD and not by either party.
FAQs
Can a bank use arbitration and SARFAESI for the same loan?
They do different things. SARFAESI enforces security; arbitration decides contractual claims. Whether both can run together on the same facts needs advice on the specific case.
What is the minimum claim for a Debt Recovery Tribunal?
Rs 20 lakh, since the Ministry of Finance notification of 6 September 2018 (S.O. 4312(E)).
Can a Lok Adalat award be appealed?
No. Section 21 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 makes it final and binding, with no appeal.
This article is general information, not legal advice.
Related on CORD: Can a bank or NBFC appoint the arbitrator? · 10 questions NBFCs should ask an ODR institution