← Back to Blog

Blog • 02 Nov 2026 • 5 mins

Can a Bank or NBFC Appoint the Arbitrator in a Loan Dispute?

A bank or NBFC cannot appoint the arbitrator in a loan dispute on its own, and choosing an ODR platform alone after the dispute arises is still a unilateral appointment. An appointment is valid when an arbitral institution makes it under rules and an appointment process that both lender and borrower agreed to before the dispute, or when a court appoints the arbitrator under section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Can a Bank or NBFC Appoint the Arbitrator in a Loan Dispute?

By Koushiik Kumar | CORD 

 

What has the Supreme Court said?

 

The Supreme Court has held that a party with an interest in the outcome of a dispute cannot appoint a sole arbitrator on its own (Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Ltd., (2020) 20 SCC 760). It built on an earlier ruling that a person who is ineligible to be an arbitrator cannot nominate one either (TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd., (2017) 8 SCC 377).

In November 2024, a five-judge bench held that the principle of equal treatment of parties applies at the stage of appointing the tribunal (Central Organisation for Railway Electrification v. ECI SPIC SMO MCML (JV), 2024 INSC 857). A clause that lets one side appoint a sole arbitrator alone does not meet that standard.

Section 12(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 adds a separate rule. A person with any of the relationships listed in the Seventh Schedule cannot act as arbitrator, whatever the contract says, unless both parties waive this in writing after the dispute has arisen.

 

Does routing the appointment through an ODR platform fix the problem?

Not if the lender chose the platform alone. In (Radiance Galore v. Yes Bank Ltd.), the Bombay High Court recorded that the award came from a unilaterally triggered appointment, even though the platform used an algorithm to select the arbitrator. The award was set aside with the bank's consent, and the Court asked two ODR platforms to explain how they comply with the law on unilateral appointments.

In (D S Textiles v. IIFL Finance Ltd), the same Court dealt with three petitions against an NBFC. Arbitrators appointed through institutional or algorithm-based routes had passed interim orders, including attachment of bank accounts. The Court held that routing an appointment through an institution of one party's choice does not cure a unilateral appointment. It recognised only two valid routes: consent of both parties, or appointment by a court under section 11. The orders were quashed, and the judgment was directed to be placed before the NBFC's board and audit committee.

 

When is an appointment through an ODR institution valid?

When both parties agreed to it before the dispute. In (Amit Chaurasia v. ICICI Bank Ltd. (2025 SCC OnLine Bom 5259, 10 December 2025), the Bombay High Court held that a pre-agreed ODR clause binds the parties, including on the appointment process run by the ODR agency the clause names.

The difference between these cases is consent. Where the loan agreement names one institution and its rules, the borrower agreed to that process when signing. Where the lender picks a platform later, the borrower agreed to nothing.

 

Judgment

Issue before the Court

Relevance to lender-appointed arbitrators

TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd., (2017) 8 SCC 377

Whether a person ineligible to be an arbitrator can nominate one

Ineligibility extends to the power to nominate

Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Ltd., (2020) 20 SCC 760

Whether a party with an interest in the dispute can appoint a sole arbitrator

It cannot, so a lender cannot appoint the arbitrator on its own

Central Organisation for Railway Electrification v. ECI SPIC SMO MCML (JV), 2024 INSC 857

Whether one-sided appointment clauses meet the principle of equal treatment

Equal treatment applies at the appointment stage

Radiance Galore v. Yes Bank Ltd., 2025:BHC-OS:10788 (Bom HC, 9 July 2025)

Challenge to an award where the bank alone chose the ODR platform and the platform's algorithm selected the arbitrator

Award set aside with the bank's consent; an algorithm does not cure a one-sided choice of platform

D S Textiles v. IIFL Finance Ltd., 2026:BHC-OS:11545 (Bom HC, 30 April 2026)

Challenges to interim orders passed by arbitrators appointed through institutions or algorithms of the NBFC's choice

An institution chosen by one party does not cure a unilateral appointment; orders quashed

Amit Chaurasia v. ICICI Bank Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine Bom 5259 (Bom HC, 10 December 2025)

Whether a pre-agreed ODR clause naming an agency binds the borrower, including its appointment process

It does: consent to a named institution before the dispute is the valid route

 

What this means for loan agreements

  • Name one arbitral institution and its rules in the clause. Do not leave the choice of institution to the lender after a dispute arises.

  • Do not give the lender a power to appoint, nominate or shortlist the arbitrator.

  • For existing loans whose clauses allow unilateral appointment, either get both parties' written agreement to an institution after the dispute arises or apply to the court under section 11.

  • Review proceedings already running under such clauses. Awards from unilaterally constituted tribunals can be set aside under section 34.

On CORD, the arbitrator is appointed under the CORD Rules 2.0 from CORD's panel, after conflict checks and disclosure, with oversight from CORD's Appointments Council. The lender does not choose the arbitrator. For new loan agreements, you can add a CORD clause to loan agreements, and CORD's approach to lending disputes is set out on its page on online arbitration for banks and NBFCs.

 

FAQs

Can a lender nominate the arbitrator if the loan agreement allows it? 

 

No. Following Perkins Eastman and CORE, a clause that lets one interested party appoint a sole arbitrator does not produce a valid appointment.

 

Is an arbitrator chosen by an algorithm automatically independent?

 

No. The Bombay High Court has held that an algorithm does not cure the defect where one party chose the platform alone (Radiance Galore; D S Textiles).

 

What makes an ODR clause valid?

 

Agreement by both parties, before the dispute, to a named institution and its rules (Amit Chaurasia v. ICICI Bank Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine Bom 5259).

 

Can a borrower challenge an arbitrator appointed by a bank?

 

Yes. The borrower can object before the tribunal that it was not validly constituted, no later than the statement of defence (section 16), challenge the arbitrator's independence or impartiality (sections 12 and 13), and apply to set aside the award (section 34). The Bombay High Court has set aside an award where the bank alone chose the ODR platform (Radiance Galore v. Yes Bank Ltd., 2025:BHC-OS:10788).

 

Who appoints an arbitrator if a bank and borrower cannot agree?

 

If the loan agreement names an arbitral institution, that institution appoints the arbitrator under its rules. If there is no agreed process, or it fails, either party can apply to the High Court under section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and the Court appoints the arbitrator.

 

Can an NBFC appoint an arbitrator through an ODR platform?

 

Not on its own. If the NBFC alone chooses the platform after the dispute arises, the appointment is still unilateral, even when the platform's algorithm selects the arbitrator (D S Textiles v. IIFL Finance Ltd., 2026:BHC-OS:11545). An ODR institution can appoint the arbitrator where the loan agreement named it and its rules, so that the borrower agreed to the process before the dispute (Amit Chaurasia v. ICICI Bank Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine Bom 5259).

 

This article is general information, not legal advice.

Related on CORD: Amit Chaurasia v. ICICI Bank · Co-lending disputes between banks and NBFCs